Google, Facebook & BBB
5.0
5.0
5.0
5.0
If you have storm damage or need a contractor to help you through the insurance process, look no further. These guys actually know what they are doing. We have dealt with 3 or 4 other contractors out of the evansville and newburgh area of southern indiana, and Winning Hand is truly unmatched. They can do it all!!
5.0
5.0
5.0
5.0
5.0
5.0
5.0
On time, efficient, and courteous. I will keep the contact information of this outfit handy for future reference.
Thank you, Bailey!!!
5.0
5.0
5.0
Winning Hand Roofing & Restoration is a roofing contractor serving Cicero, IN, homeowners throughout Hamilton County. We provide roof repair, roof replacement, storm and hail damage restoration, metal roofing, and insurance claim assistance for residential properties across Cicero and the surrounding county, backed by manufacturer-certified installation on every job.
Cicero grew up quietly on Cicero Creek after its founding in 1834, staying a small farm town for over a century. Everything changed in 1956, when the construction of Morse Reservoir put the town on the northeast shore of one of central Indiana’s largest lakes. Population nearly doubled between 1960 and 1980 and has kept climbing since, past 5,300 today, as lakefront and near-lake housing filled in around the older town core. That gives Cicero a split roofing market: modest older homes away from the water, and larger, more recent construction closer to the reservoir.
Contact us to schedule a free roof inspection for your Cicero home.
Waterfront property near Morse Reservoir attracts contractors who quote high because they assume lake homeowners will pay it without asking questions. We don’t operate that way. Every Cicero job gets the same written scope, the same materials, and the same price structure as one anywhere else in Hamilton County.
Homes closer to Morse Reservoir often have more complex rooflines and additional exposure to wind coming off open water, which we account for during inspection. We handle Hamilton County storm claims directly with your adjuster regardless of where in Cicero the property sits.
We are a GAF Certified Residential Roofing Contractor and CertainTeed ShingleMaster, available 24/7, with financing from $99 a month and 0% APR options.
Built on Repeat Customers
Most of our work comes from people who have used us before or were sent by someone who did. That only happens if you do the job right the first time.
24/7 Storm Response
Insurance Claim Friendly 
Licensed, Insured and Manufacturer Certified 
Industry-Leading Warranties Every roof we install is backed by a workmanship warranty from us and a manufacturer warranty on materials. If something goes wrong that shouldn’t, we come back and make it right.
We assess your roof top to bottom and show you exactly what we find. No cost, no pressure.
It depends on where in Cicero the home sits. A lakefront property near Morse Reservoir is a different job than an older home in town. We inspect first and price against what we find.
Size, pitch and material set the base figure, and larger homes near the reservoir tend to have more complex rooflines that add to the cost. We measure and put a defined scope in writing before quoting.
Yes. Hamilton County sees regular spring hail, and open water near Morse Reservoir can add extra wind exposure. We inspect the full roof, secure anything urgent, and are available 24/7.
If it came from a covered event, usually yes. We document every affected slope thoroughly and deal with your adjuster directly, on lakefront and inland homes alike.
Yes. Standing seam metal is a strong option near Morse Reservoir, where longer-lasting materials are worth the investment given the added wind and moisture exposure.
Yes, 24/7. We will secure the roof to stop water reaching the structure and plan the permanent repair once conditions allow.
Yes, at no cost and no obligation, with a written assessment at the end, whether your home is on the water or not.
We pay closer attention to wind exposure and complex rooflines on lakefront property, but the inspection itself is the same thorough process we use anywhere in Hamilton County.
